Must Try Gelato in Trastevere: Rome’s Creamiest Picks

Trastevere’s endless eateries serve up some of the finest food in Rome, and one thing the area does particularly well is gelato. I’ve sampled the goods in more Roman gelaterias than I can count, especially since starting my Rome food tours. Yet, I keep coming back to a handful of Trastevere joints that hit the spot every time.

Dive into any gelato-related community discussion group, and you’ll quickly notice that almost everyone has their own recommendations for where to find the best gelato in Trastevere. That said, I’m confident that with this guide, you’ll know exactly how to secure quality gelato next time you’re in Trastevere!

What Makes Truly Great Gelato?

I’ve had very few underwhelming gelato experiences, but that’s not to say that you’re guaranteed to snag top-tier scoops every time. However, there are a few things to look out for to distinguish lackluster ice cream from dreamy gelato.

• Authentic gelato will have a thick, creamy consistency and an intense flavor, as the mixture has less air than standard ice cream.
• Bright colors typically signify artificial ingredients, so it’s best to stick to muted, more neutral shades.
• Gelato should be stored in stainless steel containers and decanted with a spatula rather than a traditional ice cream scoop.
• Artisanal gelato will contain natural ingredients and will usually be prepared in-store on a daily basis. 
• If prepared correctly, gelato will be smooth and silky rather than icy or grainy, which is among the most important criteria for evaluating gelato quality.

Flavors, Traditions, and Inventive Twists

The sheer variety of flavors available in Trastevere’s gelaterias makes the neighborhood a must-visit for gelato enthusiasts! Savoring the time-honored classics is essential, but I also suggest branching out and trying some quirky or seasonal alternatives.

• Traditional flavors: You can’t go wrong with old reliables like pistachio, stracciatella, hazelnut, cioccolato, and fruit-infused gelato.
• Creative varieties: For something a little different, opt for innovative flavors like ricotta, matcha, lavender, pink peppercorn, and licorice.
• Seasonal options: Consider what produce is in season during your visit and look out for gelato flavors using these ingredients. For instance, strawberries, cherries, and peaches are in abundance throughout the summer.

Navigating the Gelato Scene in Trastevere

You don’t necessarily need a map to find the best gelato locations in Trastevere. Often, you just need to stay alert for long lines and happy customers! Nonetheless, it’s always a good idea to have some key spots on your radar before your trip.

Below are some of my top recommendations for gelato shops in Trastevere.

Via Roma Libera – Fatamorgana

Photo credit: Via Roma Libera – Fatamorgana

Fatamorgana is a modest, no-frills ice cream shop that happens to serve some of the best gelato in Trastevere. This place has become famous for its rolled sushi-style gelato treats (which are definitely worth sampling!), but my go-to order is the sweet and punchy basil and honey offering.

Fatamorgana – Open every day from 12:30 pm to 10:30 pm.

Via di San Cosimato – Otaleg

Otaleg is among the most notable gelato shops in Rome, and the variety of flavors in this modern but cozy haunt is incredible. I try to change up my order any time I visit, but I’ve yet to find anything that tops their rich, buttery pistachio gelato. For a real treat, pair this with their warm hazelnut creation!

Otaleg – Open every day from 12:00 pm to 12:00 am.

Piazza di Santa Maria – Il Gelato di Santa Maria

Photo credit: Piazza di Santa Maria – Il Gelato di Santa Maria

Il Gelato di Santa Maria may not be quite as well-known as other gelaterias in the area, but the team at this underrated gem whips some of the best gelato in Trastevere. If it’s your first visit, I suggest trying one of their crispy cones with decadent Nutella-imbued delight or refreshing lemon if you fancy something lighter.

Il Gelato di Santa Maria – Open every Monday to Thursday and Sunday from 11:00 am to 12:00 am and every Friday and Saturday from 11:00 am to 2:00 am.

Eating Like a Roman: Insider Tips

Before you begin your search for the best gelato in Trastevere, take a look at my fail-safe tips for enjoying gelato in Rome.

• Take your pick between crispy waffle cones or cups of varying sizes.
• Don’t be afraid to mix and match flavors by trying multiple varieties at once.
• Most gelaterias will allow you to sample some of the flavors before deciding which ones to order.
• Avoid adding toppings for an authentic experience.

Sources:

Eating Europe. (n.d.). Rome food tours. Eating Europe. https://www.eatingeurope.com/rome/

Gelateria Fatamorgana. (n.d.). Home. Gelateria Fatamorgana. http://www.gelateriafatamorgana.com/web/index.php

Otaleg. (n.d.). Home. Otaleg. https://www.otaleg.com/en/home_en/

Il Gelato di San Crispino. (n.d.). Il Gelato di San Crispino. Facebook. https://www.facebook.com/ilgelatodisantamaria/